Skip to content

Selling

Auction vs private sale: which is right for you?

There is no single 'best' method of sale — only the one that fits your property, timeline and current demand. Here is how auction and private sale really compare.

6 min read

All guides

How auction works

Your home is marketed for a set period leading to a public auction date. Interested buyers bid openly and, if bidding meets your confidential reserve, the highest bid wins unconditionally on the fall of the hammer — with no cooling-off period.

Auctions create urgency and visible competition, which can drive a strong result for in-demand homes. They also focus serious buyers around a single deadline.

How private sale works

The home is listed with a price or price range and buyers submit offers over time, negotiated through the agent. It is a calmer, more flexible process, and offers can include conditions (such as finance or building inspection). Buyers may have a cooling-off period.

Which suits your situation?

As a rough guide:

  • Auction often suits high-demand homes, unique properties, and rising or competitive markets
  • Private sale often suits quieter markets, niche buyers, or sellers who prefer flexibility and privacy
  • Your agent should recommend a method based on comparable recent results, not habit

This guide is general information for South East Melbourne, not legal or financial advice. Costs and rules vary and can change — confirm specifics with your agent, conveyancer or the relevant Victorian authority.

Good to know

Frequently asked questions

Is there a cooling-off period at auction?

No. A successful bid at a properly conducted public auction is binding immediately, with no cooling-off period. Private-sale contracts in Victoria generally do include a short cooling-off period (with some exceptions).

What is a reserve price?

The reserve is the confidential minimum price you are willing to accept at auction. If bidding does not reach it, the property is 'passed in' and negotiations usually continue with the highest bidder.

Which method gets a higher price?

Neither is automatically higher — it depends on the property and demand. The right method maximises competition for your specific home, which is what drives price.

Free appraisal

Your home could be on this board

It starts with an honest conversation. Book a free, obligation-free appraisal and we'll show you where your property sits — and how we'd win the campaign.